Same news, different headlines — how do you compare several newsrooms’ coverage of the same story? When something important happens in Poland — a parliamentary vote, a protest, a court ruling — within an hour a dozen or so reports of the same event appear online. The problem is that after reading three different news sites, you can come away feeling you’ve read about three different events. That’s no accident, nor the result of journalists’ incompetence (much like the psychology of clickbait headlines). It’s the result of a mechanism that communication scholars call framing — and you can recognize it if you know what to look for.
In this article I’ll show what it means for different newsrooms to frame the same event, which mechanisms are behind it, what it looks like in practice in the Polish media market (based on real academic and industry research), and how to compare several reports step by step so you can separate fact from interpretation yourself.
Why different newsrooms write “differently” about the same event
In communication studies, the phenomenon is described by two complementary theories.
Agenda-setting theory, formulated in 1972 by Maxwell McCombs and Donald Shaw at the University of North Carolina, says that the media don’t so much tell people what to think as decide what they’ll think about at all — by choosing which topics make the headlines and which are left out. In their classic study of the 1968 US presidential election, the authors showed a strong correlation between the topics that dominated the media and the topics voters considered most important.
Framing theory, in the version formulated by Robert Entman in 1993 in his now-classic article „Framing: Toward Clarification of a Fractured Paradigm”, goes a step further. According to Entman, framing consists of selection and salience: a newsroom picks certain aspects of an event and makes them more prominent in the text in a way that suggests a particular problem definition, cause, moral judgment and recommended solution. In other words — it’s not what the newsroom says outright, but what it considers important enough to put in the headline, and what it pushes to the end of the text or leaves out entirely.

What it looks like in Poland — three documented examples
Example 1: a study of TVP Info and TVN24 news tickers (London School of Economics, 2017)
One of the most precise comparative studies of Polish news media is an analysis by researcher Rafał Zaborowski, affiliated with the London School of Economics and King’s College London. The team analyzed more than 8,700 so-called “tickers” — short text messages displayed on air — from 24 hours of broadcasting on TVP Info (the public broadcaster’s news channel) and TVN24 (a commercial news channel) on November 11, 2017, during events marking Poland’s National Independence Day.
The events both channels covered were exactly the same — the same marches, the same politicians’ statements, the same course of the day. Yet the study showed that the way these events were described — word choice, tone, the emotional charge of the tickers — differed so systematically that the media began calling TVP Info’s style “tickers of dread” or “tickers of terror.” It’s a good example of how the difference doesn’t have to concern the facts as such (both channels covered the same events), but how they were packaged in language — that is, framing.
Example 2: an analysis of the main TV news programs (Towarzystwo Dziennikarskie, 2020)
Towarzystwo Dziennikarskie (the Journalists’ Society) — an organization that regularly monitors the quality of Polish news media — analyzed the three main evening TV news programs for a week (January 13–19, 2020): TVP’s “Wiadomości,” Polsat’s “Wydarzenia” and TVN’s “Fakty.” The conclusion is especially relevant to this article: the selection of news — which topics made it on air at all — didn’t differ significantly between the channels. What differed was how the same topics were presented and the opinions expressed (directly or indirectly) when presenting them.
This distinction is key: agenda-setting (what to show) and framing (how to show it) are two separate mechanisms, and this study clearly shows that the newsrooms differed mainly in the second dimension, not the first.
Example 3: how Poles rate media impartiality (CBOS)
A survey by CBOS (Poland’s Public Opinion Research Center) showed that more than half of Polish respondents (56%) believe most TV channels aren’t impartial in presenting information — a 5-percentage-point drop in trust compared with the 2017 survey. Importantly, CBOS also showed that the channel Poles get their news from is strongly correlated with their political views: viewers who identify with the right more often choose TVP1 and TVP Info, left-leaning viewers TVN and TVN24, and centrists Polsat and “Wydarzenia.”
This phenomenon, known in media research as selective exposure, closes a vicious circle: people choose sources that match their own views, which in turn reinforces the perceived credibility of those sources and distrust of the others.
These data match the international Reuters Institute Digital News Report 2025 (University of Oxford), according to which trust in the media in Poland rose to 47% in 2025 (up 8 percentage points from the previous year), though it still varies by broadcaster and is strongly tied to political polarization.
What a difference in framing looks like in practice — an illustrative example
The example below is illustrative — it shows a typical pattern of differences in framing the same fictional event (the passing of a new law), not a literal quote from any specific newsroom. The point is to illustrate the mechanism described by Entman, not to judge particular publications.
| Frame | Typical headline emphasis | What’s usually highlighted | What’s usually left out or pushed lower |
|---|---|---|---|
| Conflict | A dispute, a clash, one side’s outrage | Emotions, critics’ statements | The substantive details of the regulation itself |
| Economic | Costs, who wins and who loses | Numbers, amounts, forecasts | The political context of the decision |
| Procedural | The fact of passage, effective dates | Chronology, formal process | Controversies and dissenting voices |
Step by step: how to compare several newsrooms’ coverage yourself
The method below is based on the principle of source triangulation — a technique from qualitative research methodology that involves comparing independent sources of information about the same phenomenon to separate the common elements (probably factual) from the divergent ones (probably interpretive).

Step 1: gather at least three sources with different profiles
One public source (e.g., a public broadcaster), one commercial and one independent or foreign. The more varied the sample, the easier it is to see which elements of the coverage are common to all (probably facts) and which appear only in some versions (probably interpretation).
Step 2: compare the headline and lead separately from the body
The headline and the first paragraph (the lead) are where the newsroom makes its most important decisions about what counts as the heart of the event. It’s worth noting what made it into each report’s headline and what appeared only later in the text — that’s a direct indicator of the newsroom’s hierarchy of importance.
Step 3: mark what’s missing from each version
This is the most often skipped step in verifying information yourself. Leaving out a fact, context or side of a conflict is just as important a form of framing as word choice — Entman explicitly calls it part of the “selection” mechanism. Putting several reports side by side lets you notice which elements are missing from all of them, and take into account the selection made by each newsroom.
Step 4: check which sources each text relies on
Does the article cite specific names, documents, figures — or rather anonymous “sources close to the matter”? Texts based on verifiable sources are generally more credible than those relying mainly on vague opinions.
Step 5: build your own, composite picture of the situation
The last step is synthesis: treat as fact what is repeated in all the independent reports, and as interpretation what appears selectively, only in some of them. This way of reading the media doesn’t eliminate the need to form your own opinion, but it lets you base it on broader material than one randomly chosen report.
Why it matters — the consequences of living in a single-source bubble
As the CBOS survey cited above showed, the choice of news source in Poland is strongly tied to political views, and relying solely on one broadcaster that matches your views intensifies polarization. The 2025 Reuters Institute report also notes that in Central and Eastern European countries — including Poland — growing distrust of traditional media fosters the spread of disinformation, especially via social media, where framing mechanisms are even less transparent than in traditional newsrooms.
The habit of comparing several independent reports of the same event is one of the most effective, and at the same time simplest, ways to limit the effect of this phenomenon on your own perception of reality.
Frequently asked questions
Does this mean one of the newsrooms is “lying”?
Not necessarily. Framing usually isn’t about giving false information, but about selectively choosing true facts and words that together create a particular picture of an event. That’s why recognizing framing is harder than detecting ordinary disinformation — it requires comparison, not just checking a single fact.
Are public media more biased than commercial media?
The studies cited (LSE, Towarzystwo Dziennikarskie) point to clear differences in presentation between the public broadcaster and the commercial channels during the periods studied, but the framing mechanism — to varying degrees and in different directions — applies to practically every newsroom, regardless of ownership model.
How many sources do I need to compare to be sure?
There’s no magic number, but communication researchers recommend prioritizing a diverse range of sources over sheer quantity — three varied sources (public, commercial, independent/foreign) usually tell you more than ten sources with a similar profile.
Summary
Differences in headlines and in how different newsrooms report the same event are neither an accident nor purely the result of bias — framing is a scientifically documented mechanism, described as early as 1993 by Robert Entman and confirmed by research on the Polish media market, from the analysis of TVP Info and TVN24 tickers to monitoring by Towarzystwo Dziennikarskie. Understanding this mechanism and consciously comparing several independent reports of the same event is one of the most important skills of critical media consumption — it lets you separate what actually happened from how a newsroom chose to tell it.