Dynamic pricing: are you paying more than your neighbour? Black Friday and sellers’ tricks

Guide · Shopping and prices · Check it yourself Dark graphic: two product cards, one priced €22, the other €29, with a question mark between them, a symbol of dynamic and personalised pricing
⏱ approx. 26 min read 📚 Category: Blog 🕓 Updated: November 10, 2026

Short answer: yes, it does happen that two people see different prices for the same thing, but more often the price changes over time (demand, stock, competition) than depending on who you are. There are documented cases of price testing on a shopping platform (Instacart), demand-based ticket prices (Oasis and Ticketmaster) and the use of customer data to set prices (FTC study, 2025). In the EU, a seller using a personalised price based on automated decision-making must inform you of this no later than when you place the order. In the sources we checked, we found no Polish case of proven personalisation of the price of the same product, but there are high-profile cases of fake promotions. How do you protect yourself? Compare the price on two devices, check the price history and the lowest price in 30 days, and on Black Friday calculate your own final price.

You go to an online shop, see €29, and a friend writes that the same thing costs €22 for them. Coincidence or algorithm? This guide answers that question, shows what is documented and what is urban legend, explains the rules and describes how sellers can “set up” Black Friday deals. You’ll also find fun facts and a list of practical tips. We covered related topics in our posts on AI agents that inflate prices and on shop tricks (dark patterns).

Dynamic or personalised? Four different things

In the debate, the terms “dynamic pricing” and “personalised pricing” are often mixed up. Below is our classification. It’s not a legal definition, just a way of telling the phenomena apart.

Types of variable pricing
TypeWhat the price depends onExampleDo you see the same as your neighbour?
Dynamic pricingTime, demand, stock, competitors’ pricesTickets, flights, hotels, rides, shops with electronic price tagsUsually yes, if you check at the same moment
Personalised pricing (surveillance pricing)Data about you: location, purchase history, behaviour on the siteIndividual price adjustment by an algorithmNo
Price tests (A/B)Random assignment to a test groupThe platform shows different prices to different people to study their reactionNot necessarily
Personalised promotionsYour profile in an app or loyalty programmeA coupon “just for you”No, but the base price is the same
The key difference: a dynamic price applies to everyone at a given moment; personalisation applies to a specific person. The latter is more controversial and, under EU rules, requires informing the consumer.

Are you really paying more than your neighbour? What is documented

Below we separate what sources confirm from what is a hypothesis or rumour.

Facts, disputes and unconfirmed reports
ClaimStatusSource / notes
Companies collect customer data and use it to set prices and discountsDocumentedFTC study (January 2025): intermediaries use, among other things, location, browsing history, purchase history, mouse movements and abandoned carts
A shopping platform showed different prices for the same product to different peopleDocumentedInstacart: price tests, ended in December 2025 after a Consumer Reports publication
Ticket prices rise during the saleDocumentedOasis and Ticketmaster: the UK’s CMA secured commitments to clear information
A site showed more expensive offers to users of a particular operating systemDocumented (2012)Orbitz and Mac users: according to the WSJ, it showed them pricier hotels
Uber raises the price when your phone battery is lowUnconfirmedThe company denied it; reports based on single studies and screenshots
Airlines raise prices after several searches (cookies)DisputedAccording to the reports we read, researchers question this mechanism
In Poland, personalisation of the price of the same product in an online shop has been provenWe didn’t find thisIn the sources we checked, we only found cases of fake promotions and missing lowest-price information

Takeaway: the phenomenon is real, but its scale is hard to determine, and many high-profile stories are single screenshots. That’s why it’s worth checking prices yourself rather than assuming upfront that the shop is cheating you.

What the law says: personalised prices and the lowest price in 30 days

Rules for shoppers
RuleWhat it means for you
EU Consumer Rights Directive (as amended by Omnibus); in Poland: Consumer Rights Act, Art. 12(1)(5a)For distance contracts, the seller must inform you clearly and comprehensibly that the price has been personalised on the basis of automated decision-making, if it uses this. No later than the moment you agree to be bound by the contract
Price reduction rules (Omnibus), in force since January 1, 2023When announcing a price reduction, the shop must state the lowest price from the 30 days before the reduction and calculate the discount from that price, not from the pre-promotion price (according to prawo.pl)
Price legibilityThe price must not be shown illegibly, e.g. in too small a font or a barely visible colour
PenaltiesIn Poland, UOKiK can impose a fine of up to 10% of the previous year’s turnover for unfair market practices (according to prawo.pl). Managers face fines of up to PLN 2 million
Limitations: we didn’t check the full texts of all the provisions on exceptions to the 30-day rule. According to prawo.pl, UOKiK’s explanations of May 8, 2023 narrowed the list of promotions for which the lowest 30-day price doesn’t need to be given, but they are a non-binding interpretation. Before filing a complaint or report, check the current wording of the rules in your country.

By comparison, in the USA there is no single such rule at federal level, and the FTC is only studying the phenomenon. In a study published in January 2025, the agency said the spread of such practices “could fundamentally change how consumers buy products”, and that intermediaries had worked with at least 250 clients, including grocery and clothing stores.

Case study: five real stories

1. Instacart: same shopping, different prices (USA, 2025)

In December 2025, Consumer Reports published findings on price tests on the Instacart platform, in which different shoppers saw different prices for the same products at the same time. A day later, the Wegmans chain stopped using the software for such tests, and on December 22 Instacart announced the end of its pricing experiments, admitting that the tests “missed the mark” for some customers. The company says the software did not materially raise prices and still allows tests of promotions and discounts. In the following months, the attorneys general of New York and California and a House of Representatives committee, among others, took up the matter (according to Consumer Reports). Takeaways: it was a test, not open personalisation by wealth, but shoppers didn’t know they were seeing a different price from their neighbour. Figures from the study (e.g. the share of products with multiple prices) differ between media outlets, so we don’t repeat them here.

2. Oasis and Ticketmaster: the price rose while fans were in the queue (UK, 2024–2025)

In the sale of tickets for the reunited Oasis tour, some tickets rose from the advertised £148.50 to over £300 (e.g. to £337.50 for a standing ticket). According to the CMA, “Platinum” tickets cost almost two and a half times more than the corresponding standard ones, despite offering no extra benefits and often being in the same area. Fans in the queue weren’t warned that prices would rise once cheaper tickets sold out. After the CMA’s investigation in 2025, Ticketmaster committed, among other things, to informing about tiered pricing at least 24 hours before a sale, showing the price range on entering the queue and notifying when cheaper tickets sell out. The regulator did not demand refunds, which Which? criticised. Takeaways: dynamic pricing in itself is not illegal; the problem was the lack of clear information.

3. Orbitz: pricier hotels for Mac users (USA, 2012)

According to the Wall Street Journal, Orbitz showed Mac users more expensive hotels in search results, because statistically they chose pricier offers. It’s a historical example of “steering” offers depending on the device. It isn’t proof that the same room had a different price, but that the ranking depended on the user’s profile. Takeaway: personalisation affects not only the price, but also what you see first.

4. Zalando and Temu: UOKiK fines for missing the lowest 30-day price (Poland, 2026)

According to Telepolis (January 12, 2026), UOKiK fined Zalando PLN 31 million. The authority found that despite the Omnibus rules, Polish consumers could not verify whether discounts on the platform and in external ads were genuine, and that Zalando changed previous prices, misleading consumers and the authority. Zalando said it was analysing the decision and planned to appeal. Temu was fined PLN 6 million: on the Polish version of the site, the lowest 30-day price was not always visible, was sometimes shown for only one variant, and some “lowest prices” were not actually the lowest. Temu assured it would cooperate with UOKiK. Takeaways: checking the “pre-promotion price” is a real tool, but decisions may not be final.

5. Black Red White, Peek & Cloppenburg and Żabka Nano: UOKiK charges (Poland, April 2026)

According to rp.pl (April 29, 2026), the President of UOKiK brought charges against three companies that did not clearly show the lowest 30-day price. At Black Red White, inspectors reviewed 454 price tags and promotional materials. In one example, the promotional price was PLN 989 against a crossed-out PLN 1,439, but the lowest price in the previous 30 days was PLN 899, so the “discount” gave no saving. At Peek & Cloppenburg, 240 tags were checked, and at Żabka Nano, ads showed a reference price to the “lowest maximum” price, while the real lowest prices were only on the shelves. These are charges, not rulings: fines can reach 10% of turnover, and no amounts were given.

The common conclusion from the Polish cases

The common denominator of the Polish cases is not a “rich customer algorithm” but ordinary price fraud: an inflated pre-promotion price, a missing lowest 30-day price and misleading comparisons. For most shoppers, that is a more real risk than personalisation by profile.

Black Friday: how sellers can cheat

UOKiK warns against raising prices a few days before a promotion in order to fake attractive discounts later. The table below combines UOKiK’s recommendations with data from the cited sources. Items marked “typical” are our observations, not official findings.

Black Friday price tricks and how to check them
TrickHow it worksHow to protect yourself
Inflating the price before the promotionThe price rises a few days before Black Friday and then “drops” to its normal level (UOKiK warning)Check the price history and the lowest 30-day price
A crossed-out “regular price”A comparison with a price at which the product was hardly ever sold (typical)Compare with prices in other shops, not with the crossed-out price
The lowest 30-day price shown for one variant onlyThe information is sometimes given for one colour or size (the Temu case)Check your variant, not the first one on the list
Slogans like “deal of the day”, “exceptional offer”They suggest a bargain, but the same product often costs about the same elsewhere (UOKiK)Look for the price in at least two other shops
Package price instead of unit priceThe packaging may suggest a good price, but what counts is the price per litre or kilogram (UOKiK)Compare the price per unit of measure
Altered previous pricesThe shop modifies historical prices to make the discount look better (UOKiK’s finding against Zalando)Take a screenshot before the promotion or use an external price history
Reference to the “lowest maximum” priceThe ad shows a reference price other than the lowest in 30 days (charge against Żabka Nano)Look explicitly for “lowest price in the last 30 days”
“Up to −70%”The biggest discount applies to a few products; the rest have a small discount (typical)Look at the product’s price, not the slogan on the banner
Delivery costs and add-ons in the basketA low price rises once shipping and fees are added (typical)Compare the final price before paying
Time pressure and “last items”Timers and counters encourage hasty decisions (see dark patterns)Wait a moment, check whether the timer resets
UK data (Which?): in an analysis of 208 products in eight shops, only 5 (about 2%) were cheapest on Black Friday 2022 itself. In 98% of cases, the price was lower or the same in the six months before and after. Narrowing the window to November 18–December 2, 86% of products were still cheaper or the same price on other dates. Example: AirPods (2nd gen.) reduced from £139 to £119 on Black Friday, while costing £99–109 in the summer. It’s UK data, but it shows that the “lowest price of the year” on that Friday is often a myth.

Fun facts: 10 things about prices worth knowing

  1. Price changes during the day. According to media reports, Amazon’s prices change millions of times a day. That’s a figure from press reports, not from company data.
  2. Shelf price vs. checkout price. In 2024, Spider’s Web wrote about electronic shelf labels in Poland: Lidl had them in all stores, Biedronka in about 800 and Auchan in 61. It also described a case of bread whose price at the checkout rose from PLN 5.29 to PLN 6.79 after a price update. An older prawo.pl commentary says that in a physical shop in Poland the price on the tag applies, and if the checkout price differs, you can demand the lower one.
  3. A loyalty programme is a data set. According to an expert quoted by Spider’s Web, cards and apps give chains a lot of information about customers.
  4. The pre-promotion price can be higher than the lowest one. In the Black Red White case, the crossed-out PLN 1,439 didn’t matter, because what counted was the lowest 30-day price (PLN 899).
  5. “Platinum” tickets. In the Oasis case they cost about 2.5 times more with no extra benefits (according to the CMA).
  6. Shops with cosmetics data. The FTC described how intermediaries can, for example, target promotions by customers’ skin type (an example from the study).
  7. The mouse as a signal. According to the FTC, the data used to set prices can even include mouse movements on the page.
  8. The price of discount codes. A code “for you” in an email after an abandoned basket is often a deliberate sales strategy (typical).
  9. Fines in Poland. For pricing irregularities, UOKiK fined Zalando PLN 31 million and Temu PLN 6 million (Telepolis, 01.2026).
  10. By mid-November 2023 UOKiK had issued over 60 notices concerning Omnibus, conducted explanatory proceedings in 14 cases and brought charges in 4 (according to prawo.pl).

Tips for shoppers: 14 ways not to overpay

Practical tips (our analysis)
TipHow to do itWhy
1. Compare on two devicesCheck the price on your phone and computer, ideally without logging inYou’ll catch differences that depend on your profile or the app
2. Use a private windowOpen the site in incognito mode and compare with the logged-in viewIt’s a test, not a guarantee; no difference doesn’t prove there’s no personalisation
3. Ask a friend to checkSend the link and compare prices at the same timeThe simplest “am I paying more than my neighbour” test
4. Check the price historyUse price history on comparison sites or a web archive (see Wayback Machine)You’ll see whether the price went up before the promotion
5. Find the lowest 30-day priceLook for clear information on the lowest price from the last 30 days next to the discountNo information is a warning sign
6. Calculate the final priceAdd delivery, fees, insurance and extras before payingA low price often grows in the basket
7. Compare the unit pricePer litre, kilogram, itemPackaging can be misleading (UOKiK)
8. Wait before buyingTake a screenshot, wait a day, check whether the timer resetsFake time pressure loses its power
9. Limit data about yourselfReview your personalisation consents, log out, clear cookiesLess data means less basis for personalisation (our advice)
10. Be wary of “personalised” couponsCheck the base price without the couponA coupon can mask a high base price
11. Look for information about personalisationWhen buying online in the EU, look for a notice about individual price adjustment (Consumer Rights Directive, as amended by Omnibus)The seller is obliged to inform you
12. Take screenshotsSave the price, the date and time, and the promotion’s termsYou’ll have evidence for a complaint or report
13. Buy from a shop with a good reputationCheck whether the shop really existsFake shops use “super prices” as bait
14. Set a budget before Black FridayWrite down what you want to buy and what it usually costsYou won’t fall for a deal you don’t need
A note on VPNs and private mode: tools such as a VPN or an incognito window can change what you see, but not always, and some sites may treat this as a breach of their terms. Treat it as a test, not as a way to “get around” a price. With a VPN, also bear in mind privacy and the trustworthiness of the provider.

Check it yourself: 7 steps before you buy

1

Note the price and the time

Take a dated screenshot of the offer. That way you have a reference point if the price changes a few minutes later.

2

Compare on a second device

Open the same product in another browser or in a private window, without logging in. If the prices differ, check everything again a few minutes later.

3

Check the lowest 30-day price

Look for the information next to the discount. If it’s missing or refers to another variant, treat the promotion with caution.

4

Look at the price history

Use price history on a comparison site or a web archive. Check that the price didn’t rise just before the promotion.

5

Compare the offer in at least two shops

Take into account the final price including delivery. Remember the unit price for groceries.

6

Look for a personalisation notice

Before placing an order, read the price information. A seller using individual price adjustment based on automated decisions must tell you so.

7

Report an irregularity

If you see a fake promotion or missing lowest-price information, take a screenshot and report it to your national consumer authority (in Poland: UOKiK) or a consumer ombudsman. A report with evidence carries more weight than just an impression.

If a chatbot helps you compare prices, remember that it can make things up: see AI as a search engine.

Frequently asked questions (FAQ)

It’s prices that change over time depending on demand, stock, time of day or competitors’ prices. They usually apply to all shoppers at a given moment, e.g. tickets, flights, hotels or rides.

Dynamic prices depend on market conditions, while personalised prices depend on data about a specific customer, such as location, purchase history or behaviour on the site. In the EU, using individual prices based on automated decisions requires informing the consumer.

Sometimes, yes. Documented cases include price tests on the Instacart platform, which ended in December 2025. The scale of the phenomenon is hard to determine, and many high-profile stories are based on single screenshots.

Yes, but a seller using individual price adjustment based on automated decision-making must inform the consumer clearly, no later than when they agree to be bound by the contract (EU Consumer Rights Directive; in Poland, Art. 12(1)(5a) of the Consumer Rights Act).

In 2012, according to the WSJ, Orbitz showed Mac users more expensive hotels. In the sources we checked, we didn’t find a confirmed current case in Poland. It’s best to compare prices on two devices.

That’s unconfirmed. There have been reports and individual studies, but the company has denied it. Treat it as a hypothesis, not a fact.

The mechanism described as “cookies raise the price” is disputed. According to the reports we read, researchers question it. Flight prices do, however, change dynamically because of demand and availability.

It’s an information requirement under the EU Omnibus rules: when announcing a discount, a shop must show the lowest price from the 30 days before the reduction and calculate the saving from that price. It has applied since January 1, 2023.

Check the lowest 30-day price and the price history, and compare the offer in other shops. Also calculate the final price including delivery. Pay particular attention to prices being inflated a few days before the promotion, which UOKiK warns about.

Not always. In a 2022 Which? analysis, only about 2% of 208 products were cheapest on Black Friday itself, and 98% were cheaper or the same price in the six months before and after. That’s UK data.

According to prawo.pl, in Poland UOKiK can impose a fine of up to 10% of turnover for unfair market practices, and up to PLN 2 million on managers. In 2026, media reported UOKiK fines for Zalando (PLN 31 million) and Temu (PLN 6 million). Zalando announced an appeal.

Take a screenshot with the price, date and terms, then report it to your national consumer authority or a consumer ombudsman. A record of the pre-promotion price is good evidence.

There’s no guarantee. It’s a way to test whether the price depends on your profile, but no difference doesn’t prove there’s no personalisation. Some sites may also treat a VPN as a breach of their terms.

Technically, they allow faster price changes. According to Spider’s Web, in 2024 they were used in Poland by Lidl and Biedronka, among others. If prices differ in a physical shop in Poland, an older prawo.pl commentary says the price on the tag applies, so it’s worth pointing this out at the checkout.

Not always. A coupon is a personalised promotion, and the base price may be the same. Still, it’s worth checking the price without the coupon and comparing it with other shops.

More from our blog

Sources: Prawo.pl: rules for announcing promotions (Omnibus); Prawo.pl: fake Black Friday promotions; Polish Consumer Rights Act, Art. 12 (Standardy Prawa); Telepolis: UOKiK fines for Zalando and Temu (01.2026); Rzeczpospolita: UOKiK charges against Black Red White, Żabka and Peek&Cloppenburg (04.2026); FTC: Surveillance Pricing Study (01.2025); Consumer Reports: Instacart stops AI pricing experiments; Which?: only 2% of deals cheapest on Black Friday; Which?: Oasis, Ticketmaster and the CMA; Spider’s Web: the uberisation of prices (11.2024); News agency report: different prices for the same thing and how it works; UOKiK: home page. We describe cases from Poland and abroad based on the cited reports, not the full texts of decisions. Figures from the media (e.g. Amazon price changes) are reports. Assessments, tip tables and typologies are our analysis, not legal advice.

Scroll to Top